A heat pump heats and cools with one machine; a gas furnace heats and needs a separate air conditioner for summer. Which costs less to run depends mostly on two things you can look up: your climate and the price of gas relative to electricity.
In our model, a heat pump is cheaper to run than a gas furnace with central AC only in zone 1, the hottest. In zone 2 the two cost about the same, and from zone 3 north the furnace and AC cost less. On carbon, the heat pump wins through zone 4, ties in zone 5 and loses in zones 6 to 8.
Heat Pump vs Furnace Decision Tool
Compare yearly running cost, carbon and climate fit, with optional payback.
Running cost by climate
Yearly heating and cooling cost for the default 2,000 sq ft home, at an assumed $1.35 per therm and 18 cents per kWh:
| Climate zone | Heat pump | New furnace + AC | Cheaper to run |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zone 1 (very hot) | $1,798 | $1,968 | Heat pump |
| Zone 2 (hot) | $1,743 | $1,757 | About even |
| Zone 3 (warm) | $2,084 | $1,978 | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 4 (mixed) | $2,228 | $1,895 | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 5 (cool) | $2,964 | $1,908 | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 6 (cold) | $4,154 | $1,947 | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 7 (very cold) | $5,460 | $2,463 | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 8 (subarctic) | $6,300 | $2,794 | Furnace + AC |
Cooling comes from the calculator's five climate rows, so zones 2 and 3 share one cooling estimate, and so do zones 6, 7 and 8.
The heat loss comes from the same model as our furnace size calculator. The heat pump's heating efficiency is its HSPF2 rating, which is measured for a moderate climate; in colder zones the calculator assumes a lower seasonal HSPF2: zone 5 uses 6.5 and zones 6 to 8 use 5.0, which is why the gap widens there.
Carbon by climate
| Climate zone | Heat pump | New furnace + AC | Lower carbon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zone 1 (very hot) | 8,221 lb | 9,302 lb | Heat pump |
| Zone 2 (hot) | 7,967 lb | 9,162 lb | Heat pump |
| Zone 3 (warm) | 9,528 lb | 11,078 lb | Heat pump |
| Zone 4 (mixed) | 10,185 lb | 12,056 lb | Heat pump |
| Zone 5 (cool) | 13,554 lb | 13,624 lb | About even |
| Zone 6 (cold) | 18,991 lb | 14,935 lb | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 7 (very cold) | 24,964 lb | 19,404 lb | Furnace + AC |
| Zone 8 (subarctic) | 28,804 lb | 22,277 lb | Furnace + AC |
Electricity is counted at the U.S. grid average of 0.823 lb of carbon dioxide per kWh (EPA eGRID2022), and gas at about 117 lb per million BTU (U.S. EIA). In the three coldest zones the heat pump's lower assumed efficiency outweighs the cleaner fuel; on a cleaner grid, the heat pump's carbon advantage grows.
What changes the answer
- Energy prices. At the prices assumed here ($1.35 per therm, 18 cents per kWh) a heat pump needs a seasonal COP of about 3.75 to beat a 95% furnace on heating alone. Cheaper electricity or pricier gas tips it toward the heat pump; see gas vs. electric heating cost.
- The heat pump itself. Cold-climate models hold more of their capacity and efficiency in deep cold; see heat pumps in cold weather.
- Your air conditioner. If it needs replacing anyway, one heat pump installation replaces the air conditioner and takes over the heating.
- A dual-fuel setup pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace, which takes over below a set outdoor temperature.
Install prices and rebates
Installed prices vary too much by house and region to assume, so the calculator leaves them blank; enter your quotes to see payback and a 15-year net. Typical ranges are in our heat pump cost guide and our furnace installation cost guide.
The federal 25C tax credit ended for equipment installed after December 31, 2025. State-run HEEHR rebates cover up to $8,000[7] of a heat pump for income-qualified households, but since May 29, 2026 only when upgrading from existing electric equipment, not when replacing a gas, oil or propane furnace (DOE Program Notice 26-2)[6]; a heat pump can still be added while the furnace stays. See heat pump tax credits 2026.
Comfort
A furnace delivers short bursts of hot air, while a heat pump delivers a longer, steady stream of warm air that can feel cooler to the hand at the vent. Both keep the house at the thermostat setting. A heat pump also cools, so one system covers the whole year.
Frequently asked questions
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?
At an assumed $1.35 per therm and 18 cents per kWh, usually not: in the calculator's default home the heat pump is cheaper to run only in zone 1 and about even in zone 2, and from zone 3 north the furnace and air conditioner cost less. Cheaper electricity, pricier gas or a high-efficiency cold-climate heat pump can reverse that.
Which is better in a cold climate?
On running cost at average prices, a furnace. A cold-climate heat pump narrows the gap, and a dual-fuel system uses the heat pump in mild weather and the furnace in deep cold.
Is a heat pump better for the environment?
In most climates, yes: at the U.S. grid average the heat pump emits less carbon than the furnace and air conditioner through zone 4, about the same in zone 5, and more in the three coldest zones. On a cleaner-than-average grid it does better everywhere.
Should I replace my furnace with a heat pump?
If your air conditioner also needs replacing, you're in a mild or hot climate, or electricity is cheap where you live, a heat pump is worth pricing. Enter your quotes in the calculator to compare payback.
Sources & References
- EPA: Greenhouse Gas Equivalencies Calculator, calculations and references (eGRID2022)
- U.S. DOE: Home Energy Rebate Programs
- IRS: Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (25C)
- U.S. EIA: Electric Power Monthly (residential prices)
- PNNL-33270: Guide to Determining Climate Zones by County (2021 IECC), for the U.S. DOE
- U.S. DOE: Home Energy Rebates Program Notice 26-2 (High-Efficiency Electric Home Rebates, effective May 29, 2026)
- 42 U.S.C. 18795a (High-Efficiency Electric Home Rebate Program: 100% of cost below 80% of area median income, 50% from 80% to 150%; item caps including $8,000 heat pump)
Related Articles
Gas vs Electric Heating: Which Is Cheaper? (2026 Cost Calculator)
Comparison • 5 min read
Heat Pumps: A Homeowner's Guide to Cost, Efficiency and Cold Weather (2026)
Guide • 13 min read
Do Heat Pumps Work in Cold Weather? (Below Freezing Guide)
Guide • 8 min read
Heat Pump Installation Cost: 2026 Guide by System Type
Cost guide • 12 min read
Furnace Size Calculator: What Size Furnace Do I Need? (2026)
Calculator • 12 min read