A cracked heat exchanger is the most serious furnace problem you can face because it can leak carbon monoxide (CO) — an odorless, colorless gas responsible for 400+ deaths per year in the U.S. — directly into your home's air supply. If a technician has confirmed a crack, the furnace should be shut off and the heat exchanger replaced ($1,500–$3,500) or, more commonly, the entire furnace replaced ($3,500–$8,500) — especially if the furnace is over 15 years old.
Here are the 6 warning signs, how cracks are confirmed, what your options are, and how to protect your family.
What a Heat Exchanger Does (And Why Cracks Are Dangerous)
The heat exchanger is the metal barrier between the combustion gases (flame side) and the air you breathe (blower side). In a gas furnace, the burner fires inside the heat exchanger — a series of tubular or clamshell-shaped metal chambers. Air from your home's ductwork flows over the outside of these chambers, absorbing heat through the metal walls.
When the heat exchanger is intact, combustion byproducts (carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide, water vapor) stay sealed on the flame side and exit through the flue. When the exchanger cracks, those combustion gases can cross over into the air stream and be distributed through your ductwork to every room.
Carbon monoxide is the primary danger. CO is produced during normal gas combustion. Even a healthy furnace produces CO — it's safely vented through the flue. A cracked heat exchanger provides a path for CO to enter your living space. Low-level CO exposure causes headaches, nausea, and confusion. High-level exposure causes unconsciousness and death. Install CO detectors on every floor of your home and near sleeping areas — they are your last line of defense.
The 6 Symptoms of a Cracked Heat Exchanger
Symptom 1: Yellow or Flickering Burner Flame
A healthy gas furnace flame is steady and blue with a small yellow tip. If you look through the furnace sight glass and see a yellow, orange, or wildly flickering flame, the air-to-fuel ratio is off. A crack in the heat exchanger can disrupt combustion airflow patterns, pulling air through the crack and destabilizing the flame.
However, a yellow flame can also indicate dirty burners or incorrect gas pressure — so this symptom alone doesn't confirm a crack. It's a reason to schedule a professional inspection.
Symptom 2: Carbon Monoxide Detector Alarms
If your CO detector sounds while the furnace is running, take it seriously every time. Do not assume it's a malfunction. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) recommends evacuating immediately and calling 911.
After the home is cleared by firefighters with CO monitoring equipment, have an HVAC technician inspect the furnace before restarting it. CO alarms that coincide with furnace operation are among the strongest indicators of a cracked heat exchanger.
Symptom 3: Headaches and Flu-Like Symptoms
Low-level CO exposure mimics flu symptoms — headaches, nausea, dizziness, and fatigue. The key differentiator: symptoms improve when you leave the house and return when you come home. If multiple family members experience these symptoms simultaneously (especially during the heating season), consider CO exposure as a possible cause.
Symptom 4: Soot or Black Residue
Visible soot inside the furnace cabinet, on or around the burners, or on nearby walls and ceiling indicates incomplete combustion. While dirty burners can produce soot, significant soot production in a furnace that was previously clean may signal a heat exchanger issue allowing flue gases to affect combustion airflow.
Symptom 5: Unusual Chemical Smell
A cracked heat exchanger can allow combustion byproducts — including aldehydes and other partially combusted gases — to enter the air stream. You may notice a strong, chemical, or formaldehyde-like smell when the furnace runs. This is different from the brief "dusty" smell that occurs when a furnace first starts up for the season (which is normal and harmless).
Symptom 6: Water Leaking From the Furnace
In condensing furnaces, the secondary heat exchanger is where condensation occurs. A crack in this exchanger can allow condensate to leak in unexpected locations. This symptom overlaps with other, more common causes of furnace water leaks (like a clogged condensate drain), but if the water appears to be coming from inside the heat exchanger area rather than the drain system, a crack is possible.
How Heat Exchanger Cracks Are Confirmed
A cracked heat exchanger can only be confirmed through professional inspection. There are several methods technicians use:
Visual inspection is the most basic method. The technician removes the burner assembly to inspect the interior of the primary heat exchanger with a flashlight and mirror. Visible cracks, holes, or corrosion are definitive. However, small cracks (especially stress cracks in bends and weld joints) can be difficult to see visually.
Camera inspection uses a small flexible camera (borescope) inserted into the heat exchanger to inspect areas not visible to the naked eye. This is the most thorough inspection method and costs $100–$200 on top of a standard service call.
Combustion analysis measures CO levels in the supply air stream (the heated air going into your ducts). Elevated CO in the supply air indicates combustion gas crossover, which points to a heat exchanger breach. A combustion analyzer costs the technician $300–$1,000, which is why some budget shops skip this test.
Be cautious of the "spray test." Some technicians use a chemical tracer or match flame held near the heat exchanger to look for drafting changes that suggest a crack. While these tests can detect large cracks, they often miss small stress cracks. A combustion analysis and/or camera inspection is far more reliable. If a technician diagnoses a cracked heat exchanger, ask what method they used to confirm it. If the diagnosis is based only on a visual inspection without a camera, consider getting a second opinion.
What Causes Heat Exchangers to Crack?
The #1 preventable cause is restricted airflow from clogged filters. When the filter is blocked, the heat exchanger can't dissipate heat fast enough — internal temperatures climb above design limits, the metal expands unevenly, and stress cracks develop over time.
Repair vs. Replace: The Decision
The practical answer for most homeowners: If your furnace is under 10 years old and the heat exchanger is covered under warranty (most manufacturers offer lifetime limited warranties on heat exchangers), repair it. You'll pay labor only ($500–$1,500).
If your furnace is over 15 years old, replace the entire unit. Spending $2,000–$3,500 on a heat exchanger for a furnace that may need a blower motor, control board, or gas valve replacement in the next few years is poor economics. A new 96% AFUE furnace at $5,000–$7,000 comes with full warranties, higher efficiency, and modern features.
If your furnace is 10–15 years old, it's a judgment call. Get the repair quote, compare to replacement quotes, and consider the furnace's overall condition and your repair history.
Real-World Examples
Example 1: The Martins — CO Detector Saved Lives in Pittsburgh, PA The Martins' 19-year-old Carrier furnace had been running fine until their CO detector sounded at 2 AM during a January cold snap. They evacuated and called 911. Firefighters measured 85 ppm CO in the home (50 ppm triggers health effects). An HVAC technician found a 3-inch crack in the primary heat exchanger at a weld joint. The furnace was immediately shut down. Given the age, the Martins replaced the entire unit with a 96% AFUE model for $5,800. The CO detector — a $30 device — likely prevented a tragedy.
Example 2: The Washingtons — Warranty Saved $2,400 in Indianapolis, IN The Washingtons' 7-year-old Goodman furnace developed a crack detected during a routine annual maintenance inspection. Because the furnace was registered and under the lifetime heat exchanger warranty, Goodman covered the full cost of the replacement exchanger. The Washingtons paid only $750 for the labor to install it. Without the warranty, the total cost would have been approximately $3,150.
Example 3: The Petersons — Misdiagnosis in Chicago, IL An HVAC company told the Petersons their 12-year-old Trane furnace had a cracked heat exchanger, quoting $6,500 for a full replacement. Suspicious, they got a second opinion from a technician who used a borescope camera. No crack was found — the yellow flame was caused by a dirty burner assembly. The burner cleaning cost $175. Lesson: always get a second opinion on a cracked heat exchanger diagnosis, especially if the technician didn't use a camera or combustion analyzer.
Example 4: The Kims — Oversized Furnace Failure in Milwaukee, WI The Kims' 100,000 BTU furnace in a 1,400 sq ft home was severely oversized (needed only about 55,000 BTU per a Manual J calculation). The constant short-cycling (2–3 minute run cycles) stressed the heat exchanger, which cracked at 14 years — younger than average. When they replaced it, they right-sized to a 60,000 BTU modulating furnace. The new unit runs longer, gentler cycles, and their home is more comfortable with lower energy bills.
Key Takeaways
- A cracked heat exchanger is a safety emergency — it can leak carbon monoxide into your home. If confirmed, shut off the furnace immediately.
- The 6 warning signs are: yellow/flickering flame, CO detector alarms, headache/flu symptoms, soot/residue, chemical smell, and unexplained water.
- Confirmation requires professional inspection — preferably with a borescope camera and/or combustion analysis. Visual-only inspections can miss small cracks.
- Get a second opinion if diagnosed with a cracked heat exchanger, especially if the technician's diagnosis seems rushed or was based on visual inspection alone.
- Replace the entire furnace if it's over 15 years old. Heat exchanger replacement alone ($1,500–$3,500) rarely makes economic sense when other components are also aging.
- If the furnace is under warranty and under 10 years old, repair is usually the right call — you'll pay only labor ($500–$1,500).
- Install CO detectors on every floor and test them monthly. They are your most important safety device when you have a gas furnace.
- Prevent cracks with regular filter changes, annual professional maintenance, and proper furnace sizing at installation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
Related Articles
Related Articles
Best Electric Furnace Brands & Cost (2026 Buyer's Guide)
comparison • 8 min read
Cold Air Return Vents: What They Are & How Many You Need
guide • 10 min read
What Does a Dirty Furnace Filter Look Like? (4 Stages)
guide • 12 min read
Do Furnaces Have Pilot Lights? Which Ones Still Do (and Which Don't)
guide • 10 min read